Because fans should be critical, too

Retro: Korra: “And the Winner Is…”

B.A.S.S. Line:

No one.

Key Points:

  1. As The Legend of Korra continued its descent into dreary, perfunctory nonsense, “And the Winner Is…” used to be my one shining beacon of light. No matter how many times the series found new ways to surprise me with its incompetence, I’d always go, “At least we got ‘Winner,’ which is proof enough that, when Michael Dante DiMartino and Bryan Konietzko really concentrate their efforts, they can pull off a single fantastic episode.”
  2. That’s sadly no longer the case, and despite some flashes of brilliance here and there, “And the Winner Is…” is just another episode of Korra, plagued by the same shortcomings and lapses of judgment as any other episode. What I once misconstrued as clever storytelling was, upon close inspection, just sly manipulation designed to temporarily distract you from some blatant flaws. And for a while, it worked.
  3. The episode is a major turning point in the Book One storyline: after six episodes, Amon and the Equalists launch their first major attack during the Pro-Bending finals and officially declare war on Republic City and Benders all over the world. What started as a small radical movement has, with Amon’s leadership and with devastating technologically advanced weaponry, blossomed into a deadly terrorist organization bent on ridding the entire world of Bending.
  4. The attack is launched during the Pro-Bending finals between the Fire Ferrets (our heroes) and the Wolfbats (led by the smugly charming Tahno), which before hand, Amon had demanded to be cancelled. The City Council nearly capitulates to his demand, but thanks to the interference of Korra, and then Lin Bei Fong (who offers to provide extra security around the Pro-Bending arena), the games go as scheduled. Just as Amon wanted.
  5. For Tenzin, Tarrlok, and the rest of the Council, it’s a matter of keeping innocent lives out of potential harm’s way. For Korra and Lin, it’s a matter of pride and assertion: to give in to Amon’s demands is to basically surrender to his will. Neither can abide by that; not the Avatar, who needs to let the world know that she’s in charge now, Phasma; not Lin, who even snarks that the Council has no backbone and that she’s “expect this cut and run tactic from Tenzin.” (Tarrlok slyly makes her take full responsibility for what goes down in the arena, leaving his name in the clear.)
  6. It’s revealed here, of all places, that Tenzin and Lin used to have a romance together, but slowly drifted apart as they got older and their career paths diverged (to put it gingerly, Tenzin wanted to propagate more Airbenders, and Lin wanted to further her career as a police officer), leaving room for Pema to sweep in and lock that down. However, on this significant occasion, they agree to set their differences aside and protect the arena. (Whether it’s meaningful that their proximity to each other leads them to being distracted and being the first officers taken out by the Equalists, I’ll leave that up to you.)
  7. With all the entrances, exits, and skyways being patrolled by the Metalbending police, the Pro-Bending finals go as schedule. But there’s more trouble: Tahno and the Wolfbats are cheating, but none of their illegal moves are called by the referee. This eventually leads to one of the few successful twists in the episode, when the Fire Ferrets lose the match.
  8. But this was also anticipated by Amon, such that when the Equalist attack is in full swing, Amon rightfully calls them out as cheaters and bullies. (He missteps when using their unearned victory as an analogy for Bending oppression, but whatever.)
  9. After officially declaring the revolution a go, Amon and his cronies escape. Korra and Lin give a valiant effort to try and catch up with him, but with one thing and another, he gets away. The episode ends on a genuinely exciting cliffhanger, and its all Tenzin can do to keep from saying, “The shit just got real.”

High Points:

  1. As I said, while the episode ultimately flounders under close inspection, there are still flashes of brilliance present throughout. This is still Book One, after all, which means the direction of Joaquim Dos Santos and Ki Hyun Ryu goes a long way towards realizing even the stupidest ideas. Think of them as Ridley Scott on a bad day (see Alien: Covenant, or better yet don’t).
  2. Among the bright spots, the voice acting remains mostly top notch. Amon’s threats would be worthless spoken by anyone but Steve Blum; Rami Malek gets maybe a handful of lines as Tahno, deliciously cocky and flamboyant to start, and then suddenly sympathetic and fear-stricken when Amon takes his Bending away; voice-acting veteran Jeff “Johnny Bravo” Bennett has a grand time playing Pro-Bending commentator Shinobu, who hilariously continues his commentary even as an Equalist shoots him full of electricity; J.K. Simmons and Mindy Sterling have a good amount of chemistry as Tenzin and Lin respectively; and yes, even Dee Bradley Baker strikes a good balance as Tarrlok in this one (it’s still a shame they couldn’t get someone like, say, Armie Hammer to make Tarrlok’s upper crust smarm at least feel natural).
  3. The twist of the Fire Ferret’s defeat still works, especially since it follows a fake-out in which Korra miraculously stalls the Wolfbats’ victory by hanging off the edge of the ring and then tossing Mako back in to blast that smug grin from Tahno’s face. (His subsequent grimace always reminds me of Beavis of Beavis and Butthead, and whether that was intentional or not, it’s funny as Hell.)
  4. Following the defeat, there is the truly horrifying moment when the Equalists arise from within the Pro-Bending audience, revealing their true colors upon putting on their Equalists masks. Whether this remains chilling because of the slo-mo reveal coupled with the great doom-laced music cue, or because of the current political climate in which masked, violent, allegedly “anti-fascist” protesters have sprung into existence, I’m honestly not sure. But the moment is effective every single time. (As long as you don’t think about it too much. More on that later.)
  5. The whole sequence of the ensuing chaos in which the Equalists take out all of the police officers and take complete control of the arena is well executed. And seeing Tahno and the Wolfbats have their Bending taken away is quite effective as well.
  6. The centerpiece of the episode is the big action sequence at the end, in which Korra and Lin go after Amon on the glass dome roof of the Pro-Bending arena. The best, certainly most crowd-pleasing part is the moment when Korra, failing to Waterbend her way out of the arena, is saved by Lin and catapulted up to Amon’s zeppelin by Lin’s Metalbending cable. This is the very first time we ever see Lin in action, and it’s absolutely glorious. It’s also a rare moment of actual teamwork in the entirety of Korra.
  7. My personal favorite sequence is the fight between Korra and the Lieutenant (played by a woefully underused Lance Henriksen, perfectly matching Mr. Blum in the gravelly villain voice department). When was the last time you saw a character in the Avatar universe elbow someone in the face (let along apply direct physical hand-to-head combat on any kind)? I don’t know why, but it thrills me every time.
  8. Finally, correct me if I’m wrong, but this is the only time Pabu the [insert hybrid animal speculations here] was actually useful and relevant the entire season. And I’ll be damned if I didn’t find Bolin’s animal chatter with Pabu to be absolutely adorable.

Low Points:

  1. Pop-quiz: remember that brief moment when we see Asami and her father watching the finals from their luxury box (and Asami blows Mako a kiss, making Korra jealous)? Ever notice how you never see them again the entire episode? Not only do we not see their reaction to the Fire Ferrets’ defeat—which is weird, considering Hiroshi sponsored the team—we don’t even get their reaction to the Equalist take over, nor do we see them after the Equalists escape and the dust has settled. Why?
  2. I have two theories, neither of them positive. The first is plain old negligence: DiMartino and Konietzko (and Santos and Ryu) simply forgot about them in the midst of conceiving the more exciting stuff. Who can blame them? Six episodes in this twelve-episode mini-series, and neither Asami nor Hiroshi has developed beyond abstract ideas to the audience or plot devices for our main heroes. In that respect, it makes sense that the audience would forget them, but in-universe, Hiroshi is the richest person in Republic City. You’d think someone would remember the Satos; maybe the police officers would be especially concerned with their safety. If the Equalists were brazen enough to attack Shinobu the sports commentator, why wouldn’t they go after the noble man and his daughter?
  3. But this is where it gets suspicious: considering what we learn about Hiroshi in the very next episode—that he’s been helping the Equalists all along by supplying them with the advanced technology—it’s entirely possible that the Equalists knew to leave the Satos well alone, thus buying them time to “escape.” But if Hiroshi knew that Amon would attack the arena after the Wolfbats won, then he must have known that the game was rigged against the Fire Ferrets the entire time, leaving him unaffected by their loss. If they did include a reaction from Sato, even once, it might have given away the game too soon. Thus, the second theory is cheap manipulation: DiMartino and Konietzko intentionally kept our attention off of Hiroshi so that their twist—that he was an Equalist sympathizer all along—could have any impact.
  4. There’s a problem with this theory, though. Hiding Hiroshi’s intentions—and therefore his reactions—for the sake of the twist isn’t a terrible thing in and of itself. Instead, why not at least show us Asami’s reactions—especially since she’s basically unaware of and eventually opposed to her father’s motivations? Considering she’s the one who convinced her father to sponsor the Fire Ferrets in the first place, you’d think their defeat would have some impact on her worth noting; instead of cutting to Tenzin fruitlessly calling the referees on their lousy calls, why not show Asami disheartened and maybe even averting her father’s gaze (thus keeping Hiroshi’s own reactions obscured, killing two narrative birds with one shot)?
  5. But there’s a reason such a solution was probably never considered (or at least given time to be implemented): in DiMartino and Konietzko’s original pitch, Asami was supposed to be a villain herself. According to DiMartino, as told in The Art of The Legend of Korra: Book One: “Asami came a little later in the development process. Once we had the idea for a nonbender revolution, we knew we’d need a character who wasn’t a bender. At first, we had planned for Asami to be an Equalist spy who was using Mako to get close to Korra. But we ended up liking her so much that we thought it was better to keep her on the good guys’ side. The development process was so important for Korra, because it allowed us to play with various story and visual concepts before the full production started” (p. 22).
  6. Despite how Asami eventually turned out by the end of Book One, you can see remnants of the original idea executed in the first six episodes. By which I mean that her true colors, much like her father’s, aren’t shown until episode seven; before that, her intentions are so muddled and her personality is so vague that we could easily believe she was a spy the entire time, had DiMartino and Konietzko chosen to go that route. [Not helping matters in the slightest, the voice acting by Seychelle “Penis Hair” Gabriel is completely nondescript; for the longest time, I thought she was also voiced by Janet Varney, albeit with a higher, more feminine register than Korra’s (which would have made their forced pairing at the end of the series pretty funny).]
  7. So in a way, both theories have some merit. By neglecting to give either Asami or Hiroshi actual characterization and autonomy, DiMartino and Konietzko (and Santos and Ryu) were allowed to factor them into the story whenever it was convenient to the plot. Again, these plot twists (i.e. that Hiroshi was evil), aren’t terrible in themselves, but the foundation laid to reach them are so shoddy and disingenuous that the effect is completely nullified.
  8. This is symptomatic of the entire episode. The big reveal of the Equalists, for example, is frightening, but leaves some questions unanswered. Just how did the Equalists manage to transport all of those weapons into the arena if every single porthole and orifice was being checked and guarded by the police? With all those bombs rigged to explode after Amon made his grand exit, it’s entirely possible that the bombs, the weapons, and the equipment were all planted beforehand, but they must have been hidden pretty well for that to work. An explanation of just how the Equalists were able to pull this operation off would have been nice (and might have even made for a much more exciting episode).
  9. Having the Fire Ferrets lose the Pro-Bending finals, while surprising, also loses its impact because of how contrived it is. By contrived, I’m not referring to the Wolfbats having paid off the referee to let their illegal moves go unchallenged. That makes sense. What doesn’t make sense is how complicit the Pro-Bending fans and audience are with this behavior.
  10. I’m not much of a sports guy, but I’ve been to enough games to know that true sports fans are not just passive spectators: they know the rules of the game, what players can and can’t do, and are sometimes even quicker than the referees and commentators to pick up on foul play. And yet, here is a clearly rigged Pro-Bending match, and not a single boo is heard, not a single angry call is made. In fact, the only people who call the ref out on his shit are the sports commentator and Tenzin—the latter of whom just recently learned the rules of Pro-Bending in the first place! You’d think the Wolfbats’ victory by cheating would even incite a riot amongst the Pro-Bending viewers, which the police would then be forced to pacify. The Equalists could have even used the riot as a cover for their attack!
  11. Instead, the Equalists just take out each guard one-by-one, unopposed by the highly trained police force, and initially unnoticed by the Pro-Bending crowd. (It’s actually comical seeing the audience blissfully unfazed by the chaos ensuing around them, and I’m not sure whether I should chalk this up to negligence or budgetary constraints.)

Random Points:

  1. Early in the episode, Korra and her friends intrude on the emergency council meeting at City Hall, where they’ll vote on whether to give in to Amon’s demands or not. It’s taken for granted that Korra can just barge in on these meetings when she wants to because she’s the Avatar. Then again, maybe anyone barge in if they really want to (Lin does later). There’s no security around the entrance, and on top of that, the door isn’t even locked. Is this common procedure for the single most important decision makers in Republic City? The Equalists would be better off attacking City Hall if the council always leaves itself this vulnerable.
  2. On a more serious note, in light of recent events around the world, the poor handling of the whole Equalist plot is more disappointing than ever. Extremists groups of native and foreign origins have reared their ugly heads, destroying society and the lives of innocent people under the guise of equality and justice for all by attacking those universally perceived to be “privileged.” Ironically, if DiMartino and Konietzko had focused less on gloating about having a female of color* action hero and more on fine-tuning and presenting nuance in their tale of political unrest, they’d have been closer to the Zeitgeist than they’d previously imagined. Instead, a conflict that had enough mileage for at least two seasons was cut off after one, and not even given a satisfactory resolution. O Aaron Ehasz, where were you when we needed you!

* Yeesh, is that PC enough for you?

Conclusion:

Three-and-a-half more seasons of this shit?!

Two Weeks: Avatar: “The Waterbending Scroll” & “Jet” & “The Great Divide”

Advertisements

6 responses

  1. lukepearson

    I remember tumblr going crazy over Lin and Tenzin being an item but couldn’t care less about what happened in the episode. Also I agree with you on Lance Henriksen he is given nothing to work with and his charter is a bitch who does nothing but get kicked around I remember being so excited when it was announced that he was going to be in it, I thought that he was going to be in the army or something.

    June 25, 2017 at 1:15 pm

  2. Rosemont

    “He missteps when using their unearned victory as an analogy for Bending oppression,”

    Had the team opposing Tahno been made up of non-benders, it would’ve made more sense. But then that would defeat the purpose of pro-bending. Your theories regarding Asami’s lack of reaction and screen-time are great and supported by evidence, though my own simpler explanation is that she was conceived primarily as Mako’s satellite love interest and thus not essential to the story. The Minnie to his Mickey, so to speak.

    June 25, 2017 at 1:25 pm

    • JMR

      “He missteps when using their unearned victory as an analogy for Bending oppression,”

      I’m unsure what the misstep here is. It seems to me what he’s trying to say is that bending itself is a form of “cheating”, an unearned leg up that (possibly) comes at someone else’s expense.

      June 25, 2017 at 10:37 pm

  3. Rosemont

    I remember your “Fanservice” video on the cosplayers from this episode, and this article here really reminded me of the problem behind creating stories only dedicated fans will understand as opposed to the average viewer:

    http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/heat-vision/fans-have-inherited-film-industry-a-problem-rest-us-guest-column-1015340?utm_source=Sailthru&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=THR%20Breaking%20News_now_2017-06-29%2006:17:12_HLewis&utm_term=hollywoodreporter_breakingnews

    June 29, 2017 at 4:00 pm

  4. On a super nit-picky note, “Korra” technically has four books in two seasons. Sorry just being a brat.

    On a more serious note, in a weird way, “Korra” Book 1 arguably matches the social milieu of its time. I don’t know how long production was, but a little before “Korra” aired, the Arab Spring and “Occupy Wall Street” had just gone on the previous year (2011). I’m not versed on the former so sorry to those who know more, but in a lot of ways both movements seemed to have shown up and dissipated. This is especially true for Occupy.

    Moreover, though this is pushing it, Occupy could be considered extremism. This isn’t necessarily with respect to demands or thoughts, but methods (i.e. occupying). As Srdja Popovic, a revolutionary trainer, notes, “occupying” is a late game tactic for (non-violent) revolutionaries. Everyday people cannot be asked to drop everything and occupy a space for an indefinite period of time, hoping for change–they have to put food on the table. Consequently, you shouldn’t use occupying to start a movement.

    In a weird way then, “Korra” Book 1 could be interpreted as a commentary on addressing legitimate grievances. The Equalists may have legitimate concerns*. Unfortunately, their method of addressing these concerns aren’t attractive to the general public.
    *(E;R and others have rightfully pointed out that Bending Oppression isn’t that clear cut. Why would non-benders have it bad in Republic City?)

    For better or worse, I imagine very few people would opt to join terrorists (freedom fighters?) to push for change, since the consequences of failure are really bad. It’s perhaps not that surprising then that after Amon is defeated the Equalists immediately disband. On one hand, they probably didn’t have that much support in the first place (“The Revelation” crowd was big, but that’s probably a small fraction of the city). On the other hand, the person who could equalize bending is gone, what would even the most ardent supporters do about potential reprisals now that the Avatar has her bending back and can restore bending? (while this could count as Bending Oppression, the Benders didn’t exactly strike first)

    The potential parallel of “Korra” and modern America gets a lot stranger if you think of the four “Avatar” nations as one nation (a la “The Guru”) or the United States as multiple countries/super-states. Book 1 would be “Occupy”—a moment of change in which nothing changed, largely confined to urban areas. Book 2’s civil war might be the Presidential election–an event that is really confusing to follow, arguably in the background of everyday life, and has devastating consequences once it is finally over. Many of the critical events also take place in a neglected region (the South Pole and the Rust Belt). Book 3 would be right now—everyday people are massively hurting, relief is desperately needed, but the government is beyond incompetent. The smoke of revolution is all over.

    Book 4 is a potential future. From what I understand, the Arab Spring successfully toppled dictators, at least in Egypt, but had difficulty with the power vacuum that followed. The military then moved in (the unfortunate history of many countries). Depending on how the Second American Revolution unfolds, violently or nonviolently, well-organized or poorly organized, we may well see the end of both the American experiment and civilization at large (e.g. climate change, nuclear war, etc…).

    The final, ironic parallel may be seeing Korra (and her younger friends) as a stand-in for the Millennial generation, the overly sheltered, good-for-nothing 90s kids, who think they’re entitled to everything even though they never worked a day in their life*. Though they didn’t ask for the world they inherited, everyone’s future depends on them.

    This is especially funny after realizing all the problems in the “Korra” universe are caused by the people older than Korra, arguably Tenzin’s generation… This is akin to the Baby Boomers complaining about how the Millennials are (trophy kids) even though the Millennials were raised by Baby Boomers… The Greatest Generation casts a long shadow.
    *(I’m a Millennial, I just find some of our stereotypes funny)

    July 2, 2017 at 4:16 am

  5. Take this with a grain of salt, but according to Reddit (link below), Aaron Ehasz wanted to return for the later Books (2-4) but was too busy. I haven’t read anything about Book 1, but it seems as if Mike and Bryan wanted to do all the writing. If Aaron Ehasz did come back for Book 2 on, the Equalist plot line may have been furthered. A fan supposedly asked Ehasz about “Korra” and he said he would have wanted the Equalist plotline explored more. This question may have been before the later books came out though. Moreover, it’s hard to know how things would have played out if he returned.

    I think the real agony given America’s political climate is the lack of Book 4 for “Avatar: The Last Airbender” (it seems there are three or four independent rumor sources on this, but more later). So many shows end after the “Big Bad” is neutralized, but while this is a very pivotal moment, it’s only the beginning. Rebuilding and moving forward are just as important. The history of so many countries is sacrificing hard for freedom, only to fail in governance. It’d have been amazing if “Avatar” addressed this as the Millennials have this same tough road ahead of them. Understanding this makes me a lot more appreciative of July 4th. 241 years ago, a group of people began a revolution and successfully navigated their way to nationhood. There’s still a long journey ahead, maybe we’ll never be finished, but we’ve covered quite the distance.

    Politics aside, honestly Marshall, you and other creatives should really get together and see if you can make/remake/modernize “Avatar”. I know it sounds like a long shot, but when CS Lewis and JRR Tolkien looked around and saw a dearth of literature they cared for, they made their own so others wouldn’t have to feel the same way. The “Avatar” fandom should take a similar path.

    “Korra” can be disappointing and I think it’s right for everyone to want catharsis over that (I found your site after Book 1’s ending, since I was so upset about it). At the same time, I think we might need to take a page from Firebending (rage and destruction or energy and life?), is it “Korra” that upsets us or is it a lack of good “Avatar”?

    Reddit Source (Check Flofau’s comments)

    July 2, 2017 at 4:56 am

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s