Because fans should be critical, too

Archive for February, 2013

DiMartino’s New Blog is on the Importance of Story?

Michael Dante DiMartino has a new blog called “Why Story Matters.”

Michael Dante DiMartino, the co-creator of Avatar: the Last Airbender and The Legend of Korra, has a new blog called “Why Story Matters.”

Michael Dante DiMartino, co-creator of one of last year’s most anticipated television shows, has a new blog called “Why Story Matters.”

Michael Dante DiMartino, co-writer of one of the worst endings in a television series ever, has a new blog called “Why Story Matters.”

Michael Dante DiMartino, co-partner of one of the most disappointing cultural phenomena since the Star Wars prequels, has a new blog called “Why Story Matters.”

Michael Dante DiMartino, in a fit of guilt and reconciliation, has a new blog called “Why Story Matters.”

OK, that last part probably isn’t true (the bastard), but in any case, you should check out the blog. It’s pretty damn interesting, sometimes even insightful. I especially love this post about Death Valley and the correlation to eternal stories. It’s just a shame this blog wasn’t around when DiMartino and Konietzko were working on Korra all those years back. They might have learned something.

That picture of Mr. DiMartino is from Bryan Konietzko’s blog.

Advertisements

Announcement: No New Posts Until March

To Hell with it. Don’t expect any more updates, posts, or even silly rants like last time until at least Part One of the Korra video review is done. I can still respond to comments, replies, and questions, but I simply can’t post anything truly substantial until this review is over and done. Sorry for the inconvenience, if that.

See you in March. And Happy Valentine’s Day!


My Blog is a Sperg (And Update on “Korra” Video Review)

Korra screenshot - 3 - 16

I’d never heard the term “sperg” until a few days ago when this entire blog was referred to as such. This was apparently a reaction to a factual error on my part regarding the minute technicalities of Energybending in Avatar: the Last Airbender‘s series finale.

In my review of the finale, I proposed that Energybending still worked as a concept, even if we the audience weren’t too well prepared to deal with its application in the narrative. But here’s the detail I got wrong: the Lion Turtle says Energybending occurred before the time of the Avatar however, was thinking that previous Avatars had attempted and failed (and died) trying to Energybend because they weren’t pure at heart.

This raises a few questions: 1) if previous Avatars have died trying to attempt this ability, then wouldn’t that mean the Avatar cycle has broken a few times? Sure, but admittedly the notion does devalue (or does it?) the sacredness of the Avatar cycle, reducing it to one of those “[blank] Days Without an Accident” signs; 2) if previous Avatars did attempt it, then how come none of Aang’s past lives even knows about its existence? Maybe they were hush-hush about it because they knew it was dangerous to the Avatar cycle, and by extention their prolonged spiritual existence. Without all that stored experienced, being the Avatar would be pretty difficult and alone; 3) if this were the case, then why would Korra be able to Energybend so effortlessly? This girl is, like, the most emotionally unstable Avatar ever, but she gives Lin Bei Fong her Bending back like it was nothing. Shouldn’t she have died and destroyed the Avatar cycle? It’s not like reaching your lowest point makes you a better person. Potentially, yes, but not definitely.

Now I’m rambling, so let me make my point: it was my mistake not to consult the transcript of the finale episodes to double check precisely what the Lion Turtle said about Energybending (especially considering he only has two brief scenes of monologue). After sitting through the finale, bored most of the time, exhilarated by my favorite parts, and then losing interest once they were over, I was bound to have missed a few things. For that I apologize.

All that said, does this corrected information on Energybending change my perception or emotional reaction to the material? Not at all. I still think it’s an effective climax, just as someone else will still think it’s a cop out. In both views, we can agree that the concept was poorly established, popping up merely moments before it was relevant. I can understand if creators DiMartino and Konietzko were trying to keep the twist a secret until the very end, but they didn’t play fair. Aside from hinting at the existence of Lion Turtles, the climax (and especially Energybending) wasn’t even slightly alluded to. However you feel about the climaxes of films like, say, Jaws or Fight Club, you can’t credit the filmmakers with cheating. The climax of Avatar‘s finale, on the other hand, has a flashback in the middle of the action to reveal that the Lion Turtle said a lot more than we heard the first time we saw him. That can be considered cheating.

Long story short: I made a mistake, I admit it, even if the error in question has no real effect on my view of the show.

As for the term “sperg,” I’m still not sure I know what it even means. My guess is that it’s simply another word tossed around by Internet forum barflies that means more to them than it does to anyone else. I suppose it’s used for someone who obsesses over minute and arbitrary details that normal people miss or don’t care about (read: like someone with Asperger’s Syndrome). But if that were the case, wouldn’t I not have missed this crucial detail about Energybending and Lion Turtles?

I don’t know. I don’t know much about what’s hip with the kids these days.

ANYWAY, I should inform you all that I’m currently hard at work on The Legend of Korra video review in which I obsess over minute and arbitrary details that normal people missed or don’t care about. While the release date of March 1st is hopefully set in stone, I still wish I could have seen the Korra DVD with the commentaries and the art book first. But the DVD won’t be out until May, and the art book until July. What if the DVD and the art book finally have the answers to questions that bugged me? What if the DVD contains a heap of deleted scenes that established important details, explained character motivation better, and overall made for a more complete story than could fit into a normal television time slot and twelve episodes? Then I’ll have made a series of videos complaining about nothing!

Aw, well…


Announcement: This Will Be a Very Slow February…

I want to apologize for the lack of truly substantial updates on this blog over the past few weeks. With so much going on (school, personal troubles, the Korra video review, etc.), I haven’t been able to devote the amount of time and energy that I used to. Granted, there’s not a whole lot more I can actively contribute (except for those reviews that must be revised, like “The Puppetmaster”), but I’d rather not leave behind any unfinished business before officially calling it quits. Who knows when that will be…

In the mean time, enjoy this hastily put together trailer I made for the Korra video review, which unfortunately won’t see the like of day until March. Hopefully it’s all finished before Book Two comes out…

Marshall Turner’s Korranalysis – Teaser Trailer